KISS NEW YORK Pro Intense Gel Eyeliner with Built-in Sharpener, Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Long Lasting Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Black)

Does not cause "racoon eyes". Stays in place. Long lasting.

I like that it goes on nice and it doesn't smudge, it took a bit of effort to remove.

This is a great eyeliner pen that’s perfect for the water line. It doesn’t smudge and it’s easy to correct mistakes. The color is perfect for dark brown eyes.

I use this on water line and it stays on pretty well. I first apply little translucent power to dry area , then apply and smudge a little, then follow up with a little eyeshadow of same color. I do this with all under eye liners and it works for quite awhile. For upper eye, just go over with little eyeshadow.

This is easy to apply and doesn't get all over. It's water proof so it lasts all day, even with my watery eyes.

This eyeliner goes on smoothly & stays on the entire day & night. It's also easy to remove a "mistake" while applying without disturbing the remaining eyeliner & is easy to "blur" if you prefer to. The self-sharpening point is a real advantage which prevents keeping a pencil sharpener around (especially when traveling). It produces the same effect as my $24 eyeliner, so I highly recommend it.

It smudges. I wear it under my eye lashes and it rubs off to my contacts and leave a mark.The color is a nice dark black. I'm not a big fans since it is a bit hard to clean.

I like everything about it