Artist Color Pencil - 708 Earth by Make Up For Ever for Women - 0.05 oz Makeup

My absolute favorite eyeliner. I lost mine the other day and instantly went to go buy another one. Just be sure to have a sharpener for it, and you'll be set. It is a little bit spendy, but I think it lasts enough time and is quality enough for it to be worth it. Smudge resistance is kind of bad, I'm not gonna lie. But, it's super easy to apply and super easy to remove. So, I just carry mine with me everywhere.

Bought it again! My ride or die I wear this with all my lipsticks and lipglosses I own and it makes the shade better. I wish it was more durable but it is a lip liner after all. Not much u can ask for Lol. I also love having it under my eyelids if I forget my eyeliner. It's a great quick-makeup tool to have in your bag in case you need to fix something up. Honestly I ran through one within a year and bought another.

This pencil works great. It is not too soft and not too hard. It's good for touch ups, concealing, lip lining, and tightlining.I do wish the price was lower.

Smooth application, stays on longer when paired with Makeup Forever lipstick. Love the color!! I’m pale/brunette and it compliments me well.

Love it, matches my hair color

My absolute favorite lip liner! I will only use this brand!

I never thought I’d spend this much on a make up pencil. I bought this exact brand when I was in Disney World and lost my lip pencil so I had no choice but to go into one of the extremely overpriced stores and find this pencil. I loved it so much I decided I will continue buying them. It’s just really excellent quality and I can’t say anything bad about it. **Update 9/24/25 - the next pencil I ordered wasn’t the same. I don’t know if they’ve changed the formula or if it was old and dried out, but the tip keeps breaking off, so I am going through it very quickly. Not sure if it’s worth the price anymore. I’ll go back to Maybelline eye/lip pencils: just as good.

This eyeliner pencil is amazing! It glides on effortlessly and gives a rich, pigmented color that lasts all day without smudging. I love how precise the tip is—it makes it easy to create both bold and subtle looks. The formula is creamy but stays in place, even through long days or humid weather. Definitely a must-have in my makeup bag. I’ll be repurchasing for sure! ⸻ Let me know if you’d like to personalize it more or focus on something specific like sensitive eyes, color match, or ease of use.