MAYBELLINE New York Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Waterproof Eyeliner, Satin Finish, Pitch Brown

I’ve tried many liquid eyeliners over the years, and this one immediately impressed me with its precision, smooth application, and long-lasting formula. The fine felt-tip pen makes it easy to create clean lines, whether I want a subtle everyday look or a bold, dramatic wing. The no-skip formula is a game-changer. It glides on evenly without dragging or smudging, which is often a problem with other liquid liners. The satin finish provides a polished, professional look without being overly shiny or matte. Plus, the pitch-black color is rich and intense, delivering true pigment in just one swipe. Another standout feature is the waterproof formula. It stays put through workouts, long days, and even light rain without smudging or fading. Yet, it removes easily with my regular makeup remover, so I don’t have to tug at my delicate eye area. Durability, precision, and ease-of-use all come together perfectly in this liner. For anyone who wants reliable, high-quality eyeliner that makes application effortless, this is an excellent choice. I’ll definitely be keeping it in my everyday makeup routine as it’s precise, bold, and never disappoints. Great texture and value for money!

Excellent viscosity and drying time. Highly pigmented, this is a drug store favorite that I keep in my rotation. The brush is just the right amount of flexible, and isnt too thick so you can build how you want. Easy to use and lasted for casual use but would recommend a long wear variety for more stability.

I really like how thin this eyeliner is!!! Out of so many that I have tried I find this eyeliner to be one of the thinnest making it very precise. The brush itself is more flexible than lets say "stilla microtip" (another great eyeliner), but perhaps that is helpful when it comes to getting into the creases it wont poke you or hurt you. The slight downfall to this eyeliner is that it will dry up faster than other eyeliners.. but because it is still under $10 it is not as bad of a dealbreaker as lets say a $20 eyeliner. I think I have bought like 5 now, and will continue to buy this eyeliner. Be careful of the tip to not smush it into the cap, if you are careful then you will have nothing to worry about! Simple application and removing with makeup remover does the job!

Easily the best pen liner I've ever used. Been using this since 2017 thereabouts and I never have a reason to complain. Goes on smooth, true black, precise tip, mainly waterproof and smudge free but comes off easily with a makeup remover. I sometimes use it on my inner lash line and it never gets messy and run into my eyes. The first one I had years ago, I was carless and the tip got bent when I was placing the cap back on, and it never quite straightened back out, but that's user error, so use with care.

Bought this liner in 2024 and just dried out in 2026. It lasts a long time! Just bought a new one. I love how it just glides on. I don’t use thick liner, just a nice thin strip.

This eyeliner is okay, but I'm not a big fan of the brush tip. It frayed out pretty quickly, and I wasn't a big fan of how the product came off the brush at first compared to my others. It definitely was not my favorite tip but i got used to it . If you don't have a lot of experience, then this is not the tip for you. I did okay with it, but in the morning, I'm tired and don't always feel ad steady, and it's made a mess of your not careful, and it does smear and flow out! The good thing about this eyeliner is that it does flow off easily w little effort and has a shaker ball to stir it. It goes a long way and didn't dry out like some, so if it weren't for the brush issues, I would have gotten months more! I use my eyeliner every day, maybe skipping a day here and there, but I had this all summer and then kinda kept pulling the loose frayed to make it last longer through fall, till i got sick.of it and opened the next one discarding all the eyelin lift in the tube . It is very black, also, which is good and what i like. The brush is fine, and before it frayed, it was nice for detailing the fine line I do. I got two, so I'm hoping the second will be a better experience with the fraying of the brush because if it weren't for that, I would give it four stars! This time I'm a lot more careful with how I lay it and close it. I Make sure you lay it up because the product will flow down and make a mess because of how liquidy thin the liner is!

This eyeliner surprised me a lot. The applicator is very precise and flexible, which makes it easier to make fine lines or a cat eye type eyeliner without so much effort even if you don't have much experience

The best liner I’ve used! Finally, a pen that makes winged liners easy

This eye liner is great. Stays on all day. True water resistant it is cry proof but not rub proof which is a good thing so it is still easy to wash off. Will definitely buy it again. The line you get is perfect every time and so easy! Like 1 2 DONE GIRL! PERFECTLY pigmentated. And Best of all the price is right! I have sensitive eyes and never bothered me at all!

Excellent staying power. Completely waterproof, and super-duper easy to get a nice clean flick. Really great eyeliner.

La verdad es que es muy bueno, me gusto como pinta, la pigmentación es buena y dura mucho. Lo unico que es la segunda vez que lo compro y casi nuevo termina por abrirse y secaarse. Trae un diseño como cuadrado por lo que se se cierra y parece que queda sellado pero no, en realidad queda solo sobrepuesto y se abre.

I like a fine tip eyeliner, but the liquid ones often feel like they take forever to apply, and sometimes I need to reapply due to streakiness. This gets rid of that issue: one application is enough, no streaks or empty patches. It goes on fast too and because its a pen I feel like I have much more control. Still has a fine tip which I like. Smudge proof and I live in a crazy humid area. My new favourite.

I've been trying different brands out for the last 10 years and I've never been completely satisfied until I found this eyeliner. The quality is great, this will last me all day and night as long as I'm not rubbing my eyes too much. Once it dries, it's smudge proof and waterproof for sure. It's very easy to use! The colour is accurate and it's a perfect black.