Cobb Hill Women's Emma-CH

I am a Cobb Hill by New Balance fan. I've been eyeing these cute shoes forever and they finally dropped to $50 in 9 narrow. I was hoping these were more brown, but they are called "stone" so makes sense that they're lighter. The left foot fit well, while the right foot has a higher arch, so I'll need to put something at the back to get a better fit. I am so happy though! The insides are heaven. I have a hard time buying flats and opt for laces or Mary Jane features because my feet are so narrow that flat fall off my feet. Many flats also do not offer the proper support for my feet. These fit the bill from fit to comfort to sale price.

These shoes are great. I own a pair of Cobb Hill oxfords and absolutely love them, so I had a feeling I'd like these too. I was right. They are so comfortable! Cobb Hill nails it when it comes to comfort. The foot bed is cushioned really well, and the shoe is flexible right from the box. No need to worry about breaking them in. I wear an 8 and bought my exact shoe size; no need to buy a size up or down. They are expensive, but they are really well made. Take care of them and you'll get years of wear out of them. I would definitely recommend this brand.

3 Stars for appearance and quality of materials. I had hoped these shoes would be a great option for work. I had researched Cobb Hill, reviews were all positive, and I thought that a shoe made by an athletic shoe company must be comfortable. Unfortunately for me, these are all look and no function. Within 15 minutes of my first workday, where I sit almost the entire time, my little toe was aching. I do not have wide feet. I don't know if it is the rounding of the toe, or that these run narrow...?? I cannot return them because I've worn them. They are cute. The cushioning is less than what I was hoping for. These will get limited use as I cannot imagine wearing them on a day when I actually have to walk further than 10 feet.

I have wide feet and get a lot of pain in the soles of my feet if I wear the wrong shoes. I have bought Aravon brand (the predecessor to Cobb Hill) before and been happy with them. I normally wear shoes ranging from 8W to 9, depending on the brand/style. I initially bought these shoes in 8.5 C/D, but ended up with an 8 C/D as my heels slipped out of the 8.5. The soles have a decent amount of cushioning but there is no real arch support to speak of. I will end up putting a drug store brand insert in them for arch support, and possibly also a heel cushion to keep them on securely. But since I've struggled for months to find just one decent looking pair of flats, I will keep these shoes despite the minor flaws. The brown color is nice looking and the rubber sole is soft and flexible, and the C/D width is wide enough for my "duck feet." I have a scar on the top of my foot near my big toe and I was very happy that the edges of the leather don't rub on it and cause pain.

These are the most comfortable shoes I've ever worn right out of the box (except for my New Balance running shoes). I have wide feet,no arches and a case of plantar fasciitis and have been looking for comfortable flats for a year. THESE ARE AMAZING! Amazon suggested I get a half size smaller then my normal 8W, and they were right - the shoe is about 1/4 inch too long. But I like the looser fit and can always add heel inserts. They also are made from a nice solid leather, are flexible, don't rub and look good enough to wear with a dress or suit to work. My feet are SO happy!

I wanted to love these flats and was on the verge of keeping them when I realized they were really tight across my toebox. Perhaps that's a side effect of buying a narrow and I just have a weird foot. I think the details on this shoe are really pretty and they have a lot of padding on the inside which I liked. But, I couldn't keep them because my feet would have hurt.

I like these cute shoes! They look worn but not worn out. The color of the leather is a soft lighter chocolate brown. The toe is rounder than I anticipated from the photos, but they are cute. Heel fits perfectly. The right shoe cuts into the top of my foot just a bit where the stitching lines the opening by the toe box, but I think they could be stretched out a smidge to accommodate me. Overall, pleased. Would recommend. I think they will be comfy throughout the day.

I ordered a 7n and I wear I wear a size 7. So they do fit true to size in length. They are very cushioned and have plenty of room in toes box. I returned the shoes because one shoe (the right one) kept sliding out of my feet. I am not sure if that was a manufactured problem or my foot. I did measure my feet and they are the same width. They are very boxy and matronly looking in person, but If it had fit, I would have kept it since us narrow feet women have very few affordable shoes options at an affordable price.My search continues for a pair of flats to fit my skinny feet:(